Salt Water Taffy, 1 lb. Retro Box
Criterion salt water taffy mix contains a flavorful variety including chocolate, peanut butter, strawberry, and peppermint to name a few.
From wooden paddles to metal cooling table, Criterion still makes taffy the old fashioned way.
For more than 80 years, Criterion has been making salt water taffy and chocolates by hand with the finest of ingredients. Over three generations have enjoyed the handmade tradition of excellence.
Shop for sweet Asbury Park souvenirs for locals. Classics like Tillie and local icons available as tees, towels, stickers and gifts!
Shop for original, limited-edition t-shirts, towels, totes, stickers/pins and gifts from Wooden Wall mural artists.
Free Shipping on orders over $50. Returns & Exchanges available, please see our FAQs.
Subscribe to get special offers, free giveaways, and once-in-a-lifetime deals.